Image (4)

A commercial property does not have a single, automatic value. It has a range of possible uses, and the market pays for the use that is reasonably probable and most productive. Before an owner sets an asking price—or decides how to sell—the more important question is highest and best use: what this property can legally, physically, and economically be, and which of those uses produces the greatest value.

That question is not academic. It determines which buyers will have a reason to compete, what information they need, and whether the sale should be organized around the existing building or the land itself.

Highest and best use is not a marketing phrase. It is the disciplined answer to a practical question: what is the most productive use of this property that is legally permissible, physically possible, and financially feasible?

What the Term Actually Means

In professional appraisal practice, highest and best use is the reasonably probable use of property that results in the highest value. The four tests are legal permissibility, physical possibility, financial feasibility, and maximum productivity. The analysis is usually completed both as though the land were vacant and as the property is currently improved.

“Reasonably probable” matters. A use that would require a speculative rezoning, an unproven market, or a construction budget the numbers cannot support is not the highest and best use simply because it produces a larger figure on a spreadsheet.

The Four Tests

Legally permissible uses are those allowed by zoning, building and land-use regulations, and private restrictions such as easements, covenants, and deed limitations. Virginia law authorizes localities, by ordinance, to regulate the use of land, buildings, and structures, including their construction, alteration, or removal. The same practical constraint applies in North Carolina and West Virginia: local land-use rules, together with any private restrictions, set the legal envelope for the property. A hoped-for use is not a given until it is actually allowed, or until a change in those rules is itself reasonably probable.

Physically possible uses depend on the site and the improvements: size, shape, topography, access, utilities, soils, and the condition and layout of existing buildings. A building with a failed roof, limited access, or an awkward layout may still have a future, but the physical facts narrow the options.

Financially feasible uses are those that can justify their costs. Rehabilitation, conversion, and demolition are not free, and carrying costs continue while the work is completed. A use that cannot support those costs, after considering risk and demand, does not pass the test.

Maximally productive use is the remaining option that produces the highest value. Several uses may be legal, physical, and financially feasible. Only one is the most productive.

The Building and the Land Are Not the Same Question

For an improved property, the analysis does not stop at the current use. The existing building may already be the most productive use, or it may be more productive if renovated or converted. Or the land as though vacant, after demolition and any required site work, may be worth more than the property as it stands.

That last conclusion is uncomfortable, but it is sometimes the honest one. A distressed or functionally obsolete building can still have value. It can also be a cost. The seller who prices the property as originally designed, while serious buyers are underwriting a different use—or a clear site—will talk past the market.

Different Buyers Are Often Bidding on Different Uses

This is why highest and best use belongs at the beginning of a sale, not at the end of a stalled listing. An owner-occupant may want the building largely as it is. An investor may underwrite a converted use. A developer or adjoining owner may be buying the site. If those parties never meet under common terms and a common deadline, the seller may hear only one of those stories and mistake it for the market.

Consider an older industrial building in a small downtown: historic brick, a damaged roof, and industrial zoning. One buyer sees a rehabilitation project. Another sees an adaptive reuse that fits the neighborhood. A third is underwriting the site for something else entirely. None of them is wrong, and none of them should be priced out of the conversation by an asking price built on a single assumed use. The sale should let those competing views of use be tested in the same process, rather than treating one assumed use as if it were already the answer.

Why This Matters to the Method of Sale

An asking-price listing tends to advertise one use and one number. Buyers who see a different use may not respond, or they may respond with offers that are difficult to compare because the due-diligence, timing, and contingency terms also differ.

A well-managed auction can place those competing use cases in front of the same information, under published terms, and on a defined decision date. Each bid then reflects what the property is worth to a buyer given the use that buyer can actually carry out. Federal banking regulators’ Interagency Appraisal and Evaluation Guidelines state that an appraisal should include an opinion as to the highest and best use of the property. Sellers should expect financing buyers, and the appraisers who serve them, to ask the same use question the seller ought to have asked first.

Begin With a Clear Use Analysis

Before deciding how to sell, assemble the facts that shape use:

  • Zoning, permitted uses, and any known private restrictions.
  • Access, utilities, site size and configuration, and physical condition of the improvements.
  • Environmental information appropriate to the asset.
  • Operating history if the property is income-producing.
  • A realistic view of rehabilitation, conversion, or demolition costs, including the cost of continuing to hold the property.

The file does not have to answer every question. It does have to be honest about the questions that will control value. Once the use analysis is clear, the marketing period, bidder information, and sale terms can be built around it. The objective is not to predict a single price in advance. It is to expose the property to the buyers who have a reason to compete for it, and to let the market decide what the most productive use is worth.

Let the Market Test the Property’s Best Use

Andy Austin, MAI, CCIM, CAI, AARE, AMM, and the Double A Auction & Realty team help commercial property owners evaluate the asset and its highest and best use, define the seller’s objectives, prepare bidder information, market the opportunity, and conduct a competitive auction under clear terms.

A first conversation can determine whether the auction method fits the property and the owner’s timing. You do not need to have every detail resolved before beginning.

Visit AuctionsVirginia.com


Can’t make it to our auction?
Download our mobile bidding app to your smartphone, and bid from wherever you need to be. Works for both Apple and Android.